Why We Should Make Comedy Shows About Being Funny, Not About Being Diverse

Why We Should Make Comedy Shows About Being Funny, Not About Being Diverse
Life
Like Us On Facebook
Like Us On Facebook

I’ve been doing comedy for six years now. I’ve tried my hand at almost every form of it — improv, sketch and stand up.

Throughout all of my years in the biz, there has been an apparent, recurring problem. According to so many in the industry, there are too many white guy comedians.

A few months ago I submitted a packet to the NBC Late Night Writer’s Workshop. This is a program designed to educate comedy writers on how to hone their skills so that maybe one day, they could write for “Saturday Night Live,” “The Tonight Show” or “Late Night.”

The packet was dense. It required completing two pages of topical jokes, two pages of desk bits and two sketches (one topical and one character sketch).

Upon looking over the submission requirements, I noticed something peculiar. Under the requirements, it stated that everyone is urged to submit, “Especially those with diverse ethnic backgrounds.”

As soon as I saw that, I knew I wouldn’t be picked. I’m as non-“diverse” as they come. If diverse is what they were looking for and what they were aiming to get, I didn’t stand a chance.

I used to work at a comedy club that held a competition every year. Recently, the comedy club started holding an additional comedy festival competition, specifically for women.

Only women could enter. No boys allowed! The thing that confused me about this additional festival was that women were already incorporated in the original edition.

I understand that people want to encourage diversity in comedy (I guess?) but isn’t this a little insulting? It seems to me like the comedy club holding the competitions are saying “Oh, ladies don’t stand a chance in the regular festival. Let’s just give them their own festival.”

I do numerous shows across the city and at every show, the booker says that they have to have a girl in the show because, “We can’t have a sausage fest up there.”

So they’ll just throw any girl comic up there regardless of how funny she is or how experienced she is at comedy. It doesn’t matter what her credits are as long as she has a vagina.

That same booker will go on a hunt throughout his or her mental Rolodexes to find a “diverse” or sometimes “urban” comic to put on the show because, “We can’t just have a bunch of white guys.”

So rest assured comedy audiences, in almost every show you may attend, there will be one girl and one non-white person.

It seems to me that the comedy industry is losing sight of what is really important: BEING FUNNY.

I know quite a few women who are hilarious; some of my favorite comics in the city are girls, and I don’t think they need to be coddled.

These separate comedy festivals aimed to reward comics just for gender are ridiculous. Women don’t need special, gender-related treatment in the comedy industry — they are more than capable of holding their own, and I’ve seen it.

I’ve seen many girls blow lesser male comedians out of the water. So, why do they get preferential treatment?

Some of the best comedians of all time come from “diverse” (AKA, not white) cultural backgrounds. Richard Pryor, Chris Rock and Dave Chappelle, for example, are comedy legends.

Aziz Ansari has skyrocketed to the forefront of comedy recently. But, one thing that all of these people have in common is that they are funny FIRST.

If you’re a comedian, you shouldn’t want to be perceived at as just the “female comic” or the “Asian comic” on the show.

You should want to be the BEST comic on the show regardless of race or gender and, unfortunately, it seems that a lot of people have lost sight of that goal.

Don’t allow “sausage fest” shows. Make every show “diverse” because you’re so funny that people NEED to book you on their shows because you’re hilarious.

Don’t let people have “white guy” shows. Be funnier than all the white guys and the bookings will come.

It is fair to have an all white guy comedy show if it is comprised of funniest talent around. We should reward people for their accomplishments rather than for what they just happen to be.

If there is a female comedian who is funnier than I am, I have no issue admitting that; if there is a “diverse” comedian who kills every night, I have no problem admitting that.

What I have a problem with is the coddling of the undeserved. So, instead of relying on your race or gender, just go out there and be the funniest.

Top Photo Credit: WENN

Share Tweet
React
Like Us On Facebook
Like Us On Facebook

Joe Welkie

Joe is a stand up comedian in New York City. He has performed in venues and festivals across the country. When Joe is not doing stand up, you can usually find him alone thinking about stand up, writing new stand up, or watching stand up.

More In Life

Life WildSpiceMag

How Self-Care Has Become An Act Of Rebellion For This Generation

At some point between work, chores, laundry and unreturned emails, it dawns on me that I no longer remember what it feels like to not be overwhelmed. The way the perpetual “next thing” nips at my heels and the steady rhythm of “to-dos” pound through my head, is part of the fabric of the day. […]

Motivation Joshua Eferighe

We All Have A Gift: How To Cultivate The Genius Inside You

When Mozart was 14, he transcribed a coral setting of Psalm 50 composed in the early 1600s. A feat worth mentioning not only for his youth, but because this piece in particular was previously never written down. It was forbidden to transcribe, and it was allowed to be performed only at particular services; meaning, after […]

Life Leonardo Faria

New You, New Life: 4 Steps To Reinventing The Person In The Mirror

You look at yourself in the mirror and don’t recognize the person in the reflection. You do not like the person you are today and shudder at the mere thought of your past self. Often feeling depressed, frustrated or angry, you feel like you’re wasting your life. It’s time for a reinvention! Grab three pieces […]

Motivation Derek Neumeier

The Key To Handling Negative Circumstances Lies Within Your Reaction

We’ve all had something negative happen in our lives. You’re feeling stressed, depressed, lonely or maybe even experiencing a revolving door of these and other debilitating emotions. You normally don’t have much of an affinity towards ice cream, but all of a sudden, you’re craving some Ben & Jerry’s. Maybe you’ll pick up a couple of […]

Also On Elite

Humor

Reporter Gets Laughed Off Stage After Farting On Live TV (Video)

There are a few things in this world that I firmly believe are universally enjoyable and, in my honest opinion, people who don’t find farts funny are not to be trusted for any reason. Human beings have been trying to figure out exactly why unexpected bursts of air are so amusing since Plato first examined […]

TV

‘South Park’ Released The Full-Length Version Of The Lorde Song

Recently, “South Park” made fun of Lorde by claiming that Randy Marsh was actually the teenage crooner. It was more of a statement on the computer-aided production of music these days, rather than a jab at Lorde, which is probably why the actual Lorde took it so well. Now, the “South Park” guys released the […]

Sports

Eric Decker Shouldn’t Have Asked Twitter Followers Why They Love The Jets

Despite making all sorts of offseason moves and recent trades, the New York Jets are terrible this season. One of their most prized free agent acquisitions this summer is, of course, wide receiver Eric Decker, who joins Gang Green after playing for the Denver Broncos. He’s the dude married to that really hot girl, and […]

World

Is He Crazy? Man Boards Plane With Ebola Patient Wearing No Protective Gear

One of these things is not like the other. A crew of medical workers dressed in hazmat suits was seen boarding an airplane with Ebola patient Amber Vinson while one man, wearing no protective gear, followed. The plane was taking Vinson from Texas to Emory University Hospital in Atlanta, where she is being treated for the […]

Women

There’s A Way To Lower Teen Abortion Rates That Nobody’s Talking About

A long-term study called Contraceptive CHOICE suggests that educating low-income teenage girls and providing them with free access to intrauterine devices (IUDs) may significantly lower the rate of teenage pregnancies and abortions. The five-year study required that 1,404 teenage girls between the ages of 14 and 19 choose a form of contraception with a medical […]