New York Wants To Stop Jewish Circumcision Ritual, Claims It Causes Fatal Herpes In Babies

New York Wants To Stop Jewish Circumcision Ritual, Claims It Causes Fatal Herpes In Babies
World
Like Us On Facebook
Like Us On Facebook

After the deaths of two infants, a highly controversial Jewish circumcision practice in which the blood of a baby’s cut penis is sucked by a religious leader has been condemned .

The ‘metzitzah b’peh’–performed by ultra Orthodox Jews–is a practice in which an eight-day old baby is given a traditional circumcision, followed by the ‘mohel’ then placing his mouth around the wound and sucking up the blood.

The practice, while intended to prevent infection, has sparked controversy after the death of two infants and the contraction of herpes in at least 11 others between November 2000 and December 2011.

Heath chiefs in New York are now pushing for regulation forcing anybody wishing to have the procedure carried out on their babies to sign a consent waiver.

But some Orthodox Jews have complained about the measures claiming that they infringe on their ‘religious freedom’.

Professor of Talmudic Law and Bioethics at Yeshiva University Rabbi Moshe Tendler told KTLA that the practice was ‘primitive nonsense’.

‘The ritual has nothing to do with religion. It’s only their customs. But they’ve managed to convince the city that it’s a violation of their religious freedoms,’ he added.

Circumcision rituals originate from Scriptures, in which God tells Abraham that all men must be circumcised eight days after they are born.

Primitive Jews believed that blood was the ‘life-giving element’ and thought sucking it from the baby’s penis prevented infection.

But medical advances over the last hundred years have made clear that this practice increases the risk of infection. It is practiced widely in Israel and among Hasidic Jews.

After a death in Brooklyn last September, the city’s health department launched an investigation. A criminal investigation is still ongoing.

There was also an earlier death in November 2004, when a twin caught herpes after undergoing the procedure. The other survived.

Almost 20,500 baby boys had the procedure carried out in New York in June this year.

According to the findings of the investigation, infants who were circumcise with suction between April 2006 and December 2012 had a risk of catching neonatal herpes (HSV-1) infection of 24.4 per 100,000 cases.

New York City Health Commissioner Dr. Thomas Farley said in a statement: ‘There is no safe way to perform oral suction on any open wound in a newborn.

‘Parents considering ritual circumcision need to know that circumcision should only be performed under sterile conditions, like any other procedures that create open cuts, whether by mohelim or medical professionals.’

Jeffrey Mazlin, a certified mohel and physician in New York who regularly practices circumcision procedures, said Orthodox Jews look view the religion as ‘more important than individuals’.

‘Because blood is the life-giving element, they believe that it’s supposed to be part of the whole procedure,’ he said, adding that there were ‘no known medical benefits’.

Despite common knowledge that placing a penis–especially one with an open wound–in the oral cavity can spread disease, infectious diseases specialist Dr. Daniel S. Berman defended the practice in a paper published in the Jewish journal Dialogue. He claimed there is no evidence that the ‘metzitzah b’peh’ procedures caused the infant deaths.

Dr Berman accused New York government chiefs of ‘racial bias’.

Elite.

Share Tweet
React
Like Us On Facebook
Like Us On Facebook

Julian Sonny

From the sandy beaches of Hawaii, to the streets of New York: Julian has seen it all. His lifetime of travels has given him a broad scope of knowledge and an eclectic taste unlike any other in the tri-state area. Julian has often been compared to cultural icon, The Rock, because of his unequivocal work ethic and warrior-like stature.

More In World

World Emily Arata

Besides Being Delicious, Bacon Could Be Essential To Stopping Nosebleeds

The next time you have a nosebleed, forget the tampon. Stick a piece of cured ham up your nostril. Dr. Sonal Saraiya and her team at the Detroit Medical Center received an Ig Nobel Prize for ending a child’s unstoppable nosebleed by pushing strips of cured meat up his nose. The boy suffered from Glanzmann’s thrombasthenia, a condition […]

World Sean Levinson

Earth’s Population Could Possibly Reach 12 Billion People By 2100

A research team from the University of Washington has predicted Earth’s population to exceed 12 billion by the year 2100. Statistician and sociologist Adrian Raftery and his 13-member crew arrived to their conclusion after analyzing UN data regarding rates of fertility, death, migration and aging. The results yielded significant uncertainty on many levels, saying we […]

World Emily Arata

Pabst Blue Ribbon Will Be Sold In Russia, And Now There Will Be Even More Hipsters

In dimly-lit dive bars across the country, the American hipster is weeping. Pabst Blue Ribbon beer was once the refreshment of blue-collar workers before becoming the unofficial drink of the young hipster movement. Today, Eugene Kashper of Russia-based Oasis Beverages announced the sale of Milwaukee-based Pabst Brewing Company. PBR is a 170-year-old brand that stretches […]

Also On Elite

Sports

Indian 100-Meter Champion Has Been Suspended Because She Has ‘Too Much Testosterone’

The story of Indian track starlet Dutee Chand is just another installment in sports’ unfortunate and latest trend: women and acts of injustice coming together. A gold medalist at this year’s Asian Junior Championship, the 18-year-old runner came under the scrutiny by the Sports Authority of India for questions over her gender. According to the standards […]

Women

The Rule of 3: Why 3 Men In Your Life Is Always Better Than 1

I’ve been developing a theory over the past few months that I think has the potential to better the lives of Gen-Y women everywhere. A couple of years ago, I read Tucker Max’s “Asshole’s Finish First,” and while rummaging through the debauchery and chauvinism, I came across a glimmer of wisdom. Tucker developed a theorem […]

Women

Leaning In: Two Women Share How They’re Opening Doors For Women On Campus

Below, you’ll find personal narratives from Caroline Jureller and Leigh-Ann Williams, respectively. Both women are Campus Leaders as part of Lean In Circle’s on-campus program, which works to empower women at the collegiate level to feel capable, successful and supported as they journey beyond the classroom and into the workforce. Their stories are ones of hope and […]