Madison Beer’s rise to stardom has been steady, and at 22, she’s solidified her position as a force to be reckoned with. However, given she’s been in the public eye since 2012 (launched by Justin Bieber tweeting her cover of Etta James’ “At Last”) there’s a lot of her content out there, meaning you can track Beer’s makeup evolution over almost a decade, and wow, has it changed. Take a journey from the start of her Instagram to now see how Beer’s beauty has evolved over the years.